Insure your future...

Cottonwood Insurance Inc. is a full service independent insurance agency established in 1981. We represent many of the top independent insurance companies. We take pride in being honest, friendly, and working hard to get our customers the best insurance coverage for the most affordable price. We are a full service insurance agency offering coverage in home, auto, business, workers compensation, health, life, and bonds. We are a company built on integrity, hard work and in taking care of you, our client.

What business owners and clients say

about their partnership with Cottonwood Insurance:

  • 5 star review  Great company. We have worked with Ben Bagley for the past 5 years or so, and he is always super friendly, helpful, and quick to get us an answer on whatever questions we have!

    thumb Jane Harman
    5 years ago

    5 star review  Jason was incredibly helpful while we bought our new home. I appreciate him getting us sorted so quickly.

    thumb Carolyn Maldonado
    3 years ago
  • 5 star review  We have been with Cottonwood Insurance for many years, but just a couple months ago, out of the blue, we received an email telling us that if we switch basically the name of our insurance policy we could save a lot of money. Same exact coverage but they found a... read more

    thumb Kim W
    1 year ago

    5 star review  Did a great job catching an increase in my homeowners policy I wouldn't have noticed. Saved me $$$$. Perfect insurance agent there when you need him not when you don't. Thanks Ben Bagey!

    thumb Splash Ever
    4 years ago
  • 5 star review  I have heard advertisements about saving tons of money by many companies...Jason Basden did all of the shopping around for me and I literally saved $573 per year by switching from one insurance company to another. He does the foot get the deal!! You will not be disappointed by... read more

    thumb Michelle Kelly
    4 years ago

    5 star review  Amanda was responsive to my questions and was willing to help with pricing other insurance options should the need arise. She was very kind and thoughtful.

    thumb Troy Beynon
    2 years ago
  • 5 star review  Ryan has been helping My Customers out with their Insurance and they have been giving me Rave Reviews about his Customer Service. If my Uncle wasn't My Agent, I would be switching to Him For Sure!

    thumb Thor Edson
    8 years ago

    5 star review  I was frustrated with increasing premiums, so I reached out to see if there were any cheaper options for me. Susan got back to me the same day with comparisons from 8 different companies. She talked me through the different options and ending up saving me a lot of money... read more

    thumb Russell Boyer
    3 years ago
  • 5 star review  I have been working with Chris and his staff for years! They give Amazing service!

    thumb Denise Palmer
    2 years ago

    5 star review  I had AE Harris and he was helpful and nice. I felt that he really was trying to get me the best quote.

    thumb Jared Hunt
    3 years ago
  • 5 star review  Ryan has provided excellent service for me for over 7 years. He is always very responsive to my queries and takes the time to review my insurance needs (home, auto, earthquake, personal, etc.) and provide recommendations on the various alternatives. With Ryan, I get personalized, meaningful service.

    thumb L P
    10 years ago

    5 star review  I have been with Cottonwood Insurance for over a decade. Every time I call it is a very pleasant and easy interaction. Taylor Pizza is my agent and I refer him every chance I get!

    thumb Casey Barrett
    3 years ago
  • 5 star review  Brad Pizza - an agent with Cottonwood Insurance - is super awesome! I “inherited” him when my previous agent left Cottonwood Insurance, and I definitely won the game. Brad is helpful, concerned with getting things set up for me in a way that works for me, and gets back to... read more

    thumb Christine DelPrete
    1 year ago

    5 star review  I was so surprised at the service we got from Cottonwood Insurance, specifically Taylor Pizza. He went out of his way and went the extra mile to help us out when we needed it. He is a fantastic agent. He really changed my perspective of insurance companies.

    thumb Dakota Jake
    4 years ago
  • 5 star review  We have been with Cottonwood Insurance for many years. They have always keep us with the best rates. They are quick to respond and take care of whatever needs handling. Fast, friendly and efficient.

    thumb Maria Todd
    1 year ago

    5 star review  Cottonwood Insurance agents are great and very helpful when trying to get good quality Insurance and helps with accidents rapidly. We highly recommend them!!!!!!

    thumb Terry Stewart
    2 years ago

Fun Facts about Cottonwood Insurance

combined years of licensed service
star average on google
current clients protected
years Average customer lifetime