Insure your future...

Established in 1981, Cottonwood Insurance Inc. is a full-service independent insurance agency dedicated to protecting what matters most. Representing many of the nation's top-rated insurance carriers, we provide customized coverage options for home, auto, business, workers compensation, health, life, and bonds. Built on a foundation of integrity, hard work, and personalized service, we pride ourselves on being honest, approachable, and committed to finding the best coverage at the most competitive price. As your trusted insurance partner, we’re here to help you navigate life’s uncertainties with confidence and peace of mind.

What business owners and clients say

about their partnership with Cottonwood Insurance:

  • 5 star review  I've always had a great experience with Cottonwood Insurance Inc. They are very responsive and always professional when I'm dealing with them. I have worked closely with Jack for my auto and home insurance. I have nothing but great things to say about him. It always seems like he is... read more

    thumb Jesse Reynolds
    5 years ago

    5 star review  I can't speak highly enough of Chris Pizza and his team. He's been my insurance broker for my personal and business insurances for over 3 years. I give him a hard time by making him competitively bid out our policies every year and he beats the competition every time. He's... read more

    thumb Andrew Drage
    9 years ago
  • 5 star review  Emily was very friendly and helpful.

    thumb Ray Norton
    6 years ago

    5 star review  Did a great job catching an increase in my homeowners policy I wouldn't have noticed. Saved me $$$$. Perfect insurance agent there when you need him not when you don't. Thanks Ben Bagey!

    thumb Splash Ever
    7 years ago
  • 5 star review  I've had my Insurance with Cottonwood Insurance for a few years. I always get outstanding service. I shopped several companies before making my decision & Cottonwood Insurance was able to give me the most for my money. They are friendly, helpful and knowledgeable. I highly recommend this Insurance company!

    thumb JJ
    5 years ago

    5 star review  Brad Pizza - an agent with Cottonwood Insurance - is super awesome! I “inherited” him when my previous agent left Cottonwood Insurance, and I definitely won the game. Brad is helpful, concerned with getting things set up for me in a way that works for me, and gets back to... read more

    thumb Christine DelPrete
    5 years ago
  • 5 star review  Great company. We have worked with Ben Bagley for the past 5 years or so, and he is always super friendly, helpful, and quick to get us an answer on whatever questions we have!

    thumb Jane Harman
    8 years ago

    5 star review  Great customer service!

    thumb Mikayla Steed
    5 years ago
  • 5 star review  We had a major issue in our home over the weekend. I sent our agent, Jason, and email late Sunday night hoping that he checks his email and could give me guidance. Sure enough, within 15 minutes, he called to explain how to go about fixing the issue. I was... read more

    thumb Brett Stoddart
    8 years ago

    5 star review  I've worked with Ryan for a few years now and he's definitely the best insurance agent I've had. He's helped me through water damage at my house, changes in my car insurance, and following up when I've made changes. I know he's genuinely concerned about getting me the best help,... read more

    thumb Erika Phillips
    13 years ago
  • 5 star review  I switched to Cottonwood Insurance a few months ago and I couldn't be happier! Ben is an amazing agent and is always so quick at responding. Such a relief after dealing with unresponsive and unhelpful agents for years. I would definitely recommend Cottonwood Ins. for any of your insurance needs!

    thumb Nicholas Steedman
    6 years ago

    5 star review  I had AE Harris and he was helpful and nice. I felt that he really was trying to get me the best quote.

    thumb Jared Hunt
    7 years ago
  • 5 star review  Jason has been great to work with. He has been helping me for a couple years now. He is always on top of everything and makes sure to find me the best deals!

    thumb tshane3
    6 years ago

    5 star review  I have been working with Chris and his staff for years! They give Amazing service!

    thumb Denise Palmer
    6 years ago
  • 5 star review  We work with Justin Knudsen here at Cottonwood and have been thoroughly impressed every step of the way with our service, care, AND costs. We use Cottonwood for our personal homeowners, auto, and umbrella policies; as well as for all of our commercial policies. We have gotten great rates on... read more

    thumb Shelly Cluff
    10 years ago

    5 star review  Honest and Fair! I have been with Cottonwood Insurance for over 5 years. When we refinanced our home the mortgage broker noticed that we were paying an exorbitant amount for home insurance (to some national company) and recommended Ryan Woolston at Cottonwood. Ryan was awesome in finding us two companies... read more

    thumb L D Karford
    8 years ago

Fun Facts about Cottonwood Insurance

1
combined years of licensed service
1
star average on google
1
current clients protected
1
years Average customer lifetime